Discussion
The main finding of the present study is that under hyperglycemic conditions physiological hyperinsulinemia stimulates urinary glucose excretion in proportion to insulin sensitivity. Because the insulin-induced increment in glycosuria was paralleled by an increase in sodium excretion, the SGLT cotransporters are one potential _target of this action of insulin. Because inhibition of SGLT2 with empagliflozin did not fully prevent the glycosuric effect of insulin, it is possible that insulin may inhibit SGLT1. However, since inhibition of SGLTs by empagliflozin is incomplete (averaging 30%–40% in humans13), insulin may only partially inhibit SGLT2 (or both SGLT2 and SGLT1). In either case, this cotransport system is insulin resistant in T2D. These conclusions require qualification.
First, we tested the effect of insulin under hyperglycemic conditions to ensure complete urine collection and sufficient glycosuria to allow accurate measurement of effects in vivo. In anesthetized, instrumented animals, single-nephron micropuncture can detect much smaller effects.17 Second, our study design, by allowing enough time for stabilization of glucose and insulin concentrations, created steady-state conditions of substrate and stimulus; hence, the results may quantitatively differ from those pertaining to time-varying combinations of glycemia and insulinemia, that is, during feeding. Third, chronic rather than acute hyperinsulinemia—as prevails in insulin-resistant states and obese T2D—may alter the size of the observed effect. Finally, it is possible that supraphysiological insulin levels—as used in the early study11—may overcome the insulin resistance of sodium-glucose cotransport of patients with T2D.
Several lines of established evidence cohere with the physiological mechanism here revealed. With regard to the population sample we included in this study, the current results confirm that glucose reabsorption is inherently increased in T2D, as originally reported by Farber and colleagues in 1951,11 and later documented by DeFronzo et al,18 with the use of ascending glucose infusions. Thus, in our group of relatively well-controlled patients with T2D—comparable to those in the above-mentioned studies—fractional glucose excretion was ~20% lower than in healthy controls. Not previously reported is the concomitant reduction in sodium excretion (figure 2B), which likely subtends the characteristic volume sensitivity of the blood pressure of patients with diabetes.19 Several explanations for the increased glucose reabsorption in T2D have been invoked. In human embryonic kidney (HEK) cells, chronic incubation with high glucose concentrations increased plasma membrane expression of SGLT2 in a protein kinase A-dependent way.20 In human-cultured proximal tubular cells, pharmacological insulin concentrations (1250 µUI/mL), but not glucose, increased SGLT2 expression and protein.21 In HEK cells, insulin enhanced SGLT2, but not SGLT1, glucose transport, possibly by stimulating the translocation of SGLT2 from an intracellular pool to the S1 and S2 brush border membrane.22 Renal tubular expression of SGLT2 has been reported to be increased in diabetic Akita mice,23 in diabetic rats,24 25 in human exfoliated proximal tubular epithelial cells isolated from fresh urine in four patients with diabetes,26 and in formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded (FFPE) tissue specimens from patients with diabetic nephropathy (but not from db/db mice).27 In contrast, using FFPE biopsy specimens from patients with T2D and preserved renal function, Norton et al28 and Solini et al29 did not find any increase in SGLT2 expression. On the other hand, the expression of the insulin receptor and the levels of tyrosine phosphorylated receptor are reduced in insulin-resistant rat models30 and in renal biopsy specimens from patients with diabetes.31 Notably, in the latter study downregulation of insulin receptor levels was prominent in proximal tubules. Moreover, a _target of renal insulin signaling, namely the gluconeogenic enzyme phosphoenolpyruvate carboxykinase, which is localized to compartments near the apical membrane of proximal tubules, showed increased expression and activity. Thus, it is still possible that in T2D modulation of renal glucose-sodium reabsorption involves changes in the expression of the cotransporters (perhaps as a function of the clinical phenotype, ie, age, duration of disease, glycemic control, and so on). However, the present in vivo findings and the bulk of experimental evidence converge on the conclusion that the constitutively higher glucose reabsorption of patients with T2D is a functional manifestation of renal insulin resistance.
With regard to the effect of insulin, strong support is provided by the early studies of DeFronzo et al32 using single-nephron micropuncture in the dog, which showed that physiological hyperinsulinemia inhibits proximal tubular sodium reabsorption. In those experiments, the overall antinatriuretic effect of insulin was therefore ascribed to segments distal to the proximal tubule. Subsequent studies applying the euglycemic insulin clamp in healthy subjects33 34 confirmed these findings. Likewise, O’Hare et al35 found a reduction in sodium excretion during high-dose insulin clamp in healthy subjects but not in obese non-diabetic individuals.35
It must be emphasized that, despite efforts to maintain fluid balance the pancreatic clamp protocol was associated with an expansion of the extracellular fluid volume—as documented by a positive fluid balance (online supplementary table 4)—a drop in plasma Na+ from its normal levels (138–140 mEq/L), and an increase in urine output and eGFR (table 2). These hemodynamic changes can by themselves lead to an increased loss of both Na+ and glucose through the urine,36 and mask insulin-induced antinatriuresis. Furthermore, we estimated that the change in fluid balance between the insulin and saline periods was more positive in the controls than in the patients with T2D, mostly because of the higher exogenous GIR in the former than the latter. In consequence, the higher insulin-induced urinary excretion of solutes in controls than patients would not involve a hormonal effect on proximal tubule cotransporters. While this purely hemodynamic mechanism is apparently confirmed by our data (showing higher glucose/Na losses with insulin in controls but not T2D), it does not necessarily follow that the absolute and the fractional excretion of glucose or sodium should be selectively increased in insulin-sensitive subjects (table 1). At any rate, we cannot exclude that this mechanism may be responsible, in all or in part, for the observed effect of insulin under the experimental conditions of our study.
Also important is to consider that sodium-glucose cotransport on the luminal side of the proximal renal tubule is driven by the Na-K pump at the basolateral membrane.37 As insulin generally stimulates Na-K pump activity, sodium-glucose cotransport should be enhanced rather than reduced under hyperinsulinemic conditions. The situation, however, is more complex as the Na-K pump powers the activity of other sodium transporters (eg, sodium-hydrogen exchangers (NHE3), sodium-phosphate cotransporters, and so on9), which are also subject to multiple influences (eg, fluid drag38). Moreover, in diabetic rodents raised,39 40 decreased,41–43 or unchanged44 levels of Na-K pump activity have been described. Most of these studies were carried out in streptozotocin models of diabetes, but, to our knowledge, only one study used insulin-resistant rats.39 Insulin receptors are richly expressed in renal tubules, both on the basolateral and brush border membrane.30 In the work of Mikaelian et al,42 the reduction in Na-K pump activity was associated with a reduction of insulin binding to its receptor. A study using cultured human tubular cells showed a glucose effect to reduce Na-K pump activity and membrane protein.45 In cultured proximal tubular cells of rats a short exposure to insulin raised46 47 and a longer (24 hours) exposure reduced Na-K pump activity.48 Another study also demonstrated a dual time-dependent insulin action on Na-K pump activity, rising in the first 30 min, returning to preinsulin levels within 2 hours and decreasing after 48 hours of exposure.49 More in general, the activity of the Na-K pump in the proximal tubule is modulated by a number of stimulatory (low angiotensin II, glucocorticoids, α1 and ß-adrenergic agonists) and inhibitory factors (dopamine, parathyroid hormone and high angiotensin II), which could not be controlled in our experimental set-up. Therefore, from our results we cannot infer a reduced ability of insulin to act on the Na-K pump with any degree of certainty.
Acute SGLT2 inhibition with empagliflozin caused the expected increase in glucose and Na excretion, which was amplified by the subsequent induction of hyperglycemia. Under these conditions, superimposing hyperinsulinemia still led to a small increase in glucose and sodium excretion (table 2). This result is compatible with an insulin action on SGLT1 or a partial inhibitory effect on SGLT2 (or a combination of the two). However, the small number of subjects in this protocol coupled with the intrinsic intersubject variability of in vivo excretion rates (~30% in our hands) does not allow a more precise identification of the _target of insulin action in the proximal tubule. On the other hand, in both protocols the changes in plasma K+ concentrations and urinary excretion rates were fully as expected given that insulin is a potent stimulus for K+ uptake into extrarenal (liver and muscle) tissues.50
In summary (figure 3), the novel finding is that exogenous insulin infusion jointly reduces the reabsorption of glucose and sodium. This action is defective in insulin-resistant patients with T2D, and functionally accounts for the increased glucose reabsorption that is typical of T2D. While this insulin effect may result from a purely hemodynamic mechanism, the present data and the bulk of previous experimental evidence support the interpretation that inhibition of SGLTs in the proximal tubule is an additional mechanism. Further studies are required to characterize the molecular basis of this insulin action.
Figure 3Scheme putting the study findings into context. In the presence of acute hyperglycemia, volume expansion per se can increase glucose and sodium excretion (blue dotted line). The effect of added hyperinsulinemia is to inhibit SGLT-mediated glucose and sodium reabsorption (red dotted line). Also indicated are the stimulatory action of insulin on the sodium-hydrogen cotransporter (NHE3) and a possible inhibitory action of prolonged insulin exposure on the Na+K+ pump. See text for further explanation. GLUT, glucose transporter; SGLT, sodium-glucose cotransporters.