Psychoanalytic sociology

Psychoanalytic sociology is the research field that analyzes society using the same methods that psychoanalysis applies to analyze an individual.^[1]

'Psychoanalytic sociology embraces work from divergent sociological traditions and political perspectives': its common 'emphasis on unconscious mental processes and behavior renders psychoanalytic sociology a controversial subfield within the broader sociological discipline'^[2] (as with psychoanalysis in academic psychology).

Similarly, sociatry applies psychiatry to society itself.

History

Freud

The desire to establish a link between psychoanalysis and sociology appears very early on in Freud's work. The articles "Obsessive Actions and Religious Practices" (1907b) and " 'Civilized' Sexual Morality and Modern Nervous Illness" (1908d) are evidence of this'.^[3] Though the latter article was 'the earliest of Freud's full-length discussions of the antagonism between civilization and instinctual life, his convictions on the subject went back much further': however the 'sociological aspects of that antagonism form the main subject'^[4] in 1908.

The same mode of approach was also employed by Freud in his book Group Psychology and the Analysis of the Ego (1921), where he argued that 'crowd psychology, and with it all social psychology, is parasitic on individual psychology'.^[5] Civilization and Its Discontents in 1930 formed however his fullest sociological study, wherein he 'anchored his analysis of social and political life in a theory of human nature very much his own'.^[6]

Indeed, in 'works, from Totem and Taboo (1912-1913a) to Moses and Monotheism (1939a), Freud analyzed the events that presided over the foundation and modification of social links, the advent of civilization, and the rise of its current discontents';^[7] while James Strachey described The Future of an Illusion (1927) as 'the first of a number of sociological works to which Freud devoted most of his remaining years'.^[8]

Freudians

Freudo-Marxism

'Many of the early analysts were Marxists ... Wilhelm Reich, Paul Federn and Otto Fenichel the most notable among them', and were fully prepared, in Erich Fromm's words, to at least '"try to explain psychic structure as determined by social structure"'.^[9] Theodor Adorno's essays on psychoanalysis, reappropriated Freud's work and applied it to social phenomena,^[10] and in particular in his Freudian Theory and the Pattern of Fascist Propaganda (1951), he outlined a theory of social psychology.^[11]

In 1946, Fenichel considered that '"Comparative sociology of education" is a new scientific field of the greatest practical importance', as well as concluding in general that it is 'experience, that is, the cultural conditions, that transforms potentialities into realities, that shapes the real mental structure of man by forcing his instinctual demands into certain directions'.^[12]

Lacanian

From a different angle, the early Lacan argued that 'any "concrete psychology" must be augmented by a reference to ethnology, history and law'; and later drew on 'Lévi-Strauss's structural anthropology...[for] what will be termed the Symbolic'.^[13]

Post-Lacanians would continue to explore such sociological areas as 'the superego as the moment of common cultural binding', or the way 'the social bond, the Law binding us, is...a bond of the impossibility of obedience or disobedience'.^[14]

1960s and the Left

The 1960s saw a radical^{[need quotation to verify]} sociopsychoanalysis exert wide popular influence under the guidance of a number of different thinkers. David Cooper attempted to explore 'in terms of Freud's discovery...the social function of the family as an ideological conditioning device'.^[15] R. D. Laing 'has adapted Sartre's existential psychoanalysis..[as he] analyzes the concept of alienation':^[16] looking at the 'analysis of alienation in sociological and clinical senses', Laing concluded grandly that 'Alienation as our present destiny is achieved only by outrageous violence perpetrated by human beings on human beings'.^[17]

Norman O. Brown examined a 'politics made out of delinquency...even as the crime, so also conscience is collective'.^[18] Herbert Marcuse explored how in late modernity "repressive desublimation is indeed operative in the sexual sphere...as the by-product of the social controls of technological reality, which extend liberty while intensifying domination".^[19]

Lacanians

Duane Rousselle has developed an interventionist approach to sociological theory by highlighting the centrality of the claim made by the French psychoanalyst Jacques Lacan that "discourse is what constitutes a social bond."^[20] ^[21]

Feminist contributions

Nancy Chodorow's work has been of significance within feminist understandings, in particular The Reproduction of Mothering and The Power of Feelings. 'Although Chodorow uses a psychoanalytic approach, she rejects the instinctual determinism of the classic Freudian account in favor of a more nuanced, social psychological approach that incorporates recent developments in object relations theory'.^[22]

Jessica Benjamin has also been influential in this project of linking social theory to psychoanalysis, as with The Shadow of the Other. Juliet Mitchell however has criticised the way 'Benjamin's injunction is made within a psychosocial, not a psychoanalytical framework'.^[23]

Criticism

Freud early warned of any 'attempt of this kind to carry psychoanalysis over to the cultural community...that it is dangerous, not only with men but also with concepts, to tear them from the sphere in which they have originated and been evolved'.^[24]

Others have since observed that 'efforts to link sociology and psychoanalysis have yielded varied results....[some], intoxicated by the success of analysis, have indiscriminately applied psychoanalytic concepts to social reality and have succeeded only in bastardizing psychoanalysis (making it a management tool) and disfiguring social processes'.^[7]

References

^ Wilhelm Reich (1933) The Mass Psychology of Fascism [1]
^ K. V. Hansen/A. I. Garey, Families in the U. S. (1998) p. 297
^ Eugène Enriquez, "Sociology and Psychoanalysis/Sociopsychoanalysis"
^ Angela Richards, "Editor's Note", Sigmund Freud, Civilization, Society and Religion (PFL 12) p. 30
^ Peter Gay, Freud: A Life for Our Time (London 1989) p. 405
^ Gay, p. 547
^ ^a ^b Enriquez
^ "Chronological Table", Freud, Civilization p. 26
^ Adam Phillips, On Flirtation (London 1994) p. 134 and p. 132
^ Hammer, Espen (2006) Adorno and the political, p.60 quotation:
[...] in his later essays he tends simply to apply psychoanalysis to social phenomena.
^ Hammer (2006) p.82
^ Otto Fenichel, The Psychoanalytic Theory of Neurosis (London 1946) p. 586-8
^ David Macey, "Introduction", Jacques Lacan, The Four Fundamental Concepts of Pscho-Analysis (London 1994) p. xx and p. xxiv
^ Tony Thwaites, Reading Freud: Psychoanalysis as Cultural Theory (London 2007) p. 108 and p. 125
^ David Cooper, The Death of the Family (Penguin 1974) p. 5-6
^ Maurice Cranston, "Neocommunism and the Students' Revolts", in Studies in Comparative Communism Vol I (1968)p. 49
^ R. D. Laing, The Politics of Experience (Penguin 1984) p. 12
^ Quoted in John O'Neill, Sociology as a Skin Trade (London 1972) p. 47
^ Quoted in O'Neill, p. 51
^ Duane Rousselle, (2019) Jacques Lacan and American Sociology Palgrave.
^ Duane Rousselle, (2024) Psychoanalytic Sociology: A New Theory of the Social Bond Bloomsbury Books.
^ Hansen/Garey, p. 297
^ Quoted in Stephen Froth, For and Against Psychoanalysis (East Sussex, 2006) p. 215
^ Freud, Civilization p. 338