In research, a paper mill is a business that publishes poor or fake journal papers that seem to resemble genuine research, as well as sells authorship.[1][2]
In some cases, paper mills are sophisticated operations that sell authorship positions on legitimate research, but in many cases the papers contain fraudulent data and can be heavily plagiarized or otherwise unprofessional.[3][4] According to a report from Nature, thousands of papers in academic journals have been traced to paper mills from China, Iran and Russia, and some journals are revamping their review processes."[3] Chinese researchers have been identified as particularly prevalent customers of paper mill services.[5] Differing estimates put the share of paper mill productions between 2% and 20% of published academic papers, with particularly severe problems in some areas of biomedicine.[2][5][6]
It is a problem of research ethics and research integrity affecting academic publishing (academic writing, scientific writing and medical writing). It is an instance of academic dishonesty involving contract cheating and authorship, more specifically academic ghostwriting or medical ghostwriter. It may include data fabrication, leading to junk science, and sometimes to retractions in the scientific literature (scientific journals, academic journals, or medical journals).
Examples
edit
In early 2022, Times Higher Education and the Science Magazine News department covered a report exposing a Russian paper mill company International Publisher Ltd.[4][8] The report identified hundreds of published academic papers where positions for authorship had been sold through a Russian website allowing researchers to pay for academic prestige without requiring legitimate research contributions.[7][9] During the three-year period analyzed, 419 articles were identified that were matched to manuscripts later published in many different academic journals, with a significant bias towards publications in predatory journals.[7] While the paper mill _targeted various journals, almost 100 papers were published in International Journal of Emerging Technologies in Learning (Kassel University Press) alone, seemingly coordinated through the involvement of journal editors hosting Special Issues with space for coauthors auctioned off for anywhere from $180–5000 USD. In a separate network, guest editors and salaried academic editors for MDPI were found to coordinate sale of authorship across four different MDPI journals, totalling over 20 papers (picture, right).[7] Beyond collusion between editors and International Publisher Ltd., many legitimate research papers also sold authorship unknown to the journal editors, and were ultimately accepted in journals published by Elsevier, Oxford University Press, Springer Nature, Taylor & Francis, Wolters Kluwer, and Wiley-Blackwell. As of April 6, 2022, many of these publishers have opened an investigation into the matter.[4]
In May 2024, the Wall Street Journal published a report on fake studies that affected New Jersey publisher Wiley. More that 11,300 papers were retracted, and 19 journals were reportedly closed. The problematic papers were linked to Hindawi, an Egyptian publisher of about 250 scientific journals that Wiley acquired in 2021.[10][11] The article detailed how the research paper mill fraud worked, and highlighted individual efforts to identify and prevent future fraud. The article also warned that artificial intelligence was going to make fraud more difficult to detect.[10]
See also
editReferences
edit- ^ "Systematic manipulation of the publishing process via paper mills: Forum discussion topic September 2020". Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). Retrieved 2021-03-30.
- ^ a b Sanderson, Katharine (2024-01-19). "Science's fake-paper problem: high-profile effort will tackle paper mills". Nature. 626 (7997): 17–18. Bibcode:2024Natur.626...17S. doi:10.1038/d41586-024-00159-9. PMID 38243120.
- ^ a b Else, Holly; Van Noorden, Richard (2021-03-23). "The fight against fake-paper factories that churn out sham science". Nature. 591 (7851): 516–519. Bibcode:2021Natur.591..516E. doi:10.1038/d41586-021-00733-5. PMID 33758408.
- ^ a b c Chawla, Dalmeet (2022-04-06). "Russian site peddles paper authorship in reputable journals for up to $5000 a pop". www.science.org. Retrieved 2022-04-12.
- ^ a b "China's fake science industry: how 'paper mills' threaten progress". www.ft.com. 2023.
- ^ "Fake scientific papers are alarmingly common". Science. 2023-05-09.
- ^ a b c d Abalkina, Anna (October 2023). "Publication and collaboration anomalies in academic papers originating from a paper mill: evidence from a Russia-based paper mill". Learned Publishing. 36 (4): 689–702. arXiv:2112.13322. doi:10.1002/leap.1574.
- ^ "Academic fraud factories are booming, warns plagiarism sleuth". Times Higher Education (THE). 2022-01-19. Retrieved 2023-03-15.
- ^ "Publication and Collaboration Anomalies in Academic Papers Originating From a Russian-Based Paper Mill". Peer Review Congress. Retrieved 2023-03-15.
- ^ a b Subbaraman, Nidhi (May 15, 2024). "Exclusive | Flood of Fake Science Forces Multiple Journal Closures". Wall Street Journal. Retrieved May 15, 2024.
- ^ "Wiley Announces the Acquisition of Hindawi". Wiley.com. January 5, 2021. Retrieved May 24, 2024.