Rich BucklerReviews
Author of Black Panther (Penguin Classics Marvel Collection)
41+ Works 313 Members 9 Reviews
Reviews
Fantastic Four Omnibus volume 5 DM cover
Flagged
CaptainCraig | Dec 8, 2024 | Access a version of the below that includes illustrations on my blog.
This is the Black Panther's first ongoing series, a run in Jungle Action by Don McGregor, which is made up of two stories: Panther's Rage and The Panther vs. the Klan! The first story takes T'Challa back to Wakanda after his sojourn to America, along with his girlfriend Monica, who I guess must be from some Avengers stories I haven't read. Panther's Rage inspired the Black Panther movie, as it's about an attempt by Erik Killmonger to depose T'Challa from the throne of Wakanda.
At the same time he wrote this, Don McGregor was also writing Killraven, of which I am a big fan, and this is very similar: wordy and portentous, perhaps verging into pretentious, with a large emphasis on character and theme. Like Killraven, it has a lot of the trappings of superhero comics, but it is not one. Panther's Rage is a war comic, a war in a nation, a war in a people, and a war in one man. He fights grotesque villains working for Killmonger, but it's more like a fever dream at times, surreal battles that are really there to illuminate what's happening inside T'Challa
I can't say I always liked it. It gets a bit repetitive at times, and the ongoing plot doesn't move very quickly. Sometimes there were just so many words. The series had eleven different letterers across its eighteen issues, and I can see why: why do more than two issues of this when you can go letter some Captain America comic with half the dialogue and none of the narration? But Billy Graham and Rich Buckler capture power in their layouts and art, and sometimes the thing whole rises to poetry.
McGregor builds up a recurring cast around T'Challa, and I look forward to seeing if future writers keep these people's lives going. Indeed, if the story has a single success, it's in convincing you that though Wakanda is a strange place, it is a real place. It is a country with people and history and geography and conflict. I suspect that will be its legacy.
This makes it all the more inexplicable that for its second arc, McGregor had T'Challa go to the American South with Monica to investigate the apparent suicide of her sister. The Ku Klux Klan plays a big role, as does a not-the-KKK organization, the Dragon Clan. Gone are all the characters and history he had so painstakingly built up; T'Challa himself suddenly feels less plausible as he for some reason never takes off his Black Panther outfit. There are still fun parts—Monica's solitaire-obsessed father—and interesting imagery, but the investigation moves at a crawl, and nothing has really happened at the point where the story suddenly ends because the book was cancelled for low sales.
Don McGregor and his collaborators would be soon replaced by Jack Kirby. (Somewhat weirdly, Marvel would actually get another writer and artist to finish the Klan storyline in three issues of Marvel Premiere, over three years after Jungle Action was cancelled. Like, why? If it wasn't worth doing at the time, why was it worth doing years later? I cannot imagine a comics publisher nicely capping off a mediocre run like this now. Those issues of Marvel Premiere are in another Marvel Masterworks Presents The Black Panther volume, but alas that one is not on Hoopla.)
This is the Black Panther's first ongoing series, a run in Jungle Action by Don McGregor, which is made up of two stories: Panther's Rage and The Panther vs. the Klan! The first story takes T'Challa back to Wakanda after his sojourn to America, along with his girlfriend Monica, who I guess must be from some Avengers stories I haven't read. Panther's Rage inspired the Black Panther movie, as it's about an attempt by Erik Killmonger to depose T'Challa from the throne of Wakanda.
At the same time he wrote this, Don McGregor was also writing Killraven, of which I am a big fan, and this is very similar: wordy and portentous, perhaps verging into pretentious, with a large emphasis on character and theme. Like Killraven, it has a lot of the trappings of superhero comics, but it is not one. Panther's Rage is a war comic, a war in a nation, a war in a people, and a war in one man. He fights grotesque villains working for Killmonger, but it's more like a fever dream at times, surreal battles that are really there to illuminate what's happening inside T'Challa
I can't say I always liked it. It gets a bit repetitive at times, and the ongoing plot doesn't move very quickly. Sometimes there were just so many words. The series had eleven different letterers across its eighteen issues, and I can see why: why do more than two issues of this when you can go letter some Captain America comic with half the dialogue and none of the narration? But Billy Graham and Rich Buckler capture power in their layouts and art, and sometimes the thing whole rises to poetry.
McGregor builds up a recurring cast around T'Challa, and I look forward to seeing if future writers keep these people's lives going. Indeed, if the story has a single success, it's in convincing you that though Wakanda is a strange place, it is a real place. It is a country with people and history and geography and conflict. I suspect that will be its legacy.
This makes it all the more inexplicable that for its second arc, McGregor had T'Challa go to the American South with Monica to investigate the apparent suicide of her sister. The Ku Klux Klan plays a big role, as does a not-the-KKK organization, the Dragon Clan. Gone are all the characters and history he had so painstakingly built up; T'Challa himself suddenly feels less plausible as he for some reason never takes off his Black Panther outfit. There are still fun parts—Monica's solitaire-obsessed father—and interesting imagery, but the investigation moves at a crawl, and nothing has really happened at the point where the story suddenly ends because the book was cancelled for low sales.
Don McGregor and his collaborators would be soon replaced by Jack Kirby. (Somewhat weirdly, Marvel would actually get another writer and artist to finish the Klan storyline in three issues of Marvel Premiere, over three years after Jungle Action was cancelled. Like, why? If it wasn't worth doing at the time, why was it worth doing years later? I cannot imagine a comics publisher nicely capping off a mediocre run like this now. Those issues of Marvel Premiere are in another Marvel Masterworks Presents The Black Panther volume, but alas that one is not on Hoopla.)
Flagged
Stevil2001 | 1 other review | Mar 25, 2023 | CrÃtica | Pantera Negra de Ed Hannigan e Jerry Bingham
http://www.planocritico.com/critica-pantera-negra-de-ed-hannigan-e-jerry-bingham...
http://www.planocritico.com/critica-pantera-negra-de-ed-hannigan-e-jerry-bingham...
Flagged
lulusantiago | 1 other review | Mar 11, 2023 | Quando Terras Colidem: https://www.planocritico.com/critica-superman-vs-shazam-1978-1984/
Flagged
lulusantiago | 1 other review | Mar 11, 2023 | Superman, Shazam e FamÃlia Marvel: https://www.planocritico.com/critica-superman-vs-shazam-1978-1984/
Flagged
lulusantiago | Mar 11, 2023 | Superman, Shazam e FamÃlia Marvel: https://www.planocritico.com/critica-superman-vs-shazam-1978-1984/
Flagged
lulusantiago | Mar 11, 2023 | The plot was good but could have been better without the over the top cheesy dialogue at times. The artwork was not my favorite, it has a 70-80 grit look with no vibrance.
I did enjoy the character Rahne, I really want to read more about her so I plan on googling comics that she appears in. She was a spunky red head kid with an awesome pixie cut.
I did enjoy the character Rahne, I really want to read more about her so I plan on googling comics that she appears in. She was a spunky red head kid with an awesome pixie cut.
Flagged
Koralis | Jul 12, 2022 | A fairly flimsy storyline provides an excuse for DC to pit two of its strongest heroes against each other in this graphic novel, pawns of a plan to destroy their two earths. Poor story, middling artwork. Comics have improved so much in the last couple of decades.½
Flagged
burnit99 | 1 other review | Jan 5, 2007 | This is a miniature version of the large comic book series. Title from page 1 is “The Superman Story.â€?
Flagged
fredheid | Mar 20, 2006 | This site uses cookies to deliver our services, improve performance, for analytics, and (if not signed in) for advertising. By using LibraryThing you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. Your use of the site and services is subject to these policies and terms.