HomeGroupsTalkMoreZeitgeist
Search Site
This site uses cookies to deliver our services, improve performance, for analytics, and (if not signed in) for advertising. By using LibraryThing you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. Your use of the site and services is subject to these policies and terms.

Results from Google Books

Click on a thumbnail to go to Google Books.

Good-Bye and Amen by Beth Gutcheon
Loading...

Good-Bye and Amen (edition 2008)

by Beth Gutcheon (Author)

MembersReviewsPopularityAverage ratingMentions
12912224,346 (3)1
I got swept into the drama very quickly, and the family was deliciously dysfunctional. As were the churches - this just nailed church politics. I found out this book was a continuation of [b:Leeway Cottage|895410|Leeway Cottage|Beth Gutcheon|https://images.gr-assets.com/books/1348964207s/895410.jpg|880604], and now I want to go back to the library and find that book as well.

I did want to see how some of the secondary conflicts ultimately played out, but perhaps that's material for a sequel. Also, I could never figure out who exactly the ghostly narrator was, although that could be because I hadn't read Leeway Cottage first.

I also appreciated the brief biographies of each character at the back of the book. I only wish I had found it sooner. It would have made things so much easier if it had been at the beginning.

Some quotes I enjoyed:

"Andrew Carnegie said that if you die rich, you die disgraced. Well, Mother will be safe with Andrew, if they meet in heaven. She'd been living beyond her means for years. Way beyond." (Page 4).

"Apparently once Rachel threw his suits into the bathtub and set them on fire so he wouldn't have anything to wear to work. That's not normal. But I begin to think there may well have been two sides to that story." (Page 28). You don't say...

"There are always two sides in a marriage. Always. At least two." (Page 28).

"Once I understood where the ring came from, I wanted it. It's hard, dividing this stuff. It isn't really bits of stone and metal and wood. It's the history of our family. Who loved who, who was cruel, who was kind." (Page 52). On a larger scale, this is why we need archeologists and indeed the entire field of archeology.

"I once worked in a school where they'd had a really pugnacious head. He couldn't get along with anyone, although he'd come with great recommendations. Turns out the last school gave him glowing recs because they wanted to get rid of him." (Page 62). I laughed so hard. ( )
  Jennifer708 | Mar 21, 2020 |
Showing 11 of 11
I got swept into the drama very quickly, and the family was deliciously dysfunctional. As were the churches - this just nailed church politics. I found out this book was a continuation of [b:Leeway Cottage|895410|Leeway Cottage|Beth Gutcheon|https://images.gr-assets.com/books/1348964207s/895410.jpg|880604], and now I want to go back to the library and find that book as well.

I did want to see how some of the secondary conflicts ultimately played out, but perhaps that's material for a sequel. Also, I could never figure out who exactly the ghostly narrator was, although that could be because I hadn't read Leeway Cottage first.

I also appreciated the brief biographies of each character at the back of the book. I only wish I had found it sooner. It would have made things so much easier if it had been at the beginning.

Some quotes I enjoyed:

"Andrew Carnegie said that if you die rich, you die disgraced. Well, Mother will be safe with Andrew, if they meet in heaven. She'd been living beyond her means for years. Way beyond." (Page 4).

"Apparently once Rachel threw his suits into the bathtub and set them on fire so he wouldn't have anything to wear to work. That's not normal. But I begin to think there may well have been two sides to that story." (Page 28). You don't say...

"There are always two sides in a marriage. Always. At least two." (Page 28).

"Once I understood where the ring came from, I wanted it. It's hard, dividing this stuff. It isn't really bits of stone and metal and wood. It's the history of our family. Who loved who, who was cruel, who was kind." (Page 52). On a larger scale, this is why we need archeologists and indeed the entire field of archeology.

"I once worked in a school where they'd had a really pugnacious head. He couldn't get along with anyone, although he'd come with great recommendations. Turns out the last school gave him glowing recs because they wanted to get rid of him." (Page 62). I laughed so hard. ( )
  Jennifer708 | Mar 21, 2020 |
I got swept into the drama very quickly, and the family was deliciously dysfunctional. As were the churches - this just nailed church politics. I found out this book was a continuation of [b:Leeway Cottage|895410|Leeway Cottage|Beth Gutcheon|https://images.gr-assets.com/books/1348964207s/895410.jpg|880604], and now I want to go back to the library and find that book as well.

I did want to see how some of the secondary conflicts ultimately played out, but perhaps that's material for a sequel. Also, I could never figure out who exactly the ghostly narrator was, although that could be because I hadn't read Leeway Cottage first.

I also appreciated the brief biographies of each character at the back of the book. I only wish I had found it sooner. It would have made things so much easier if it had been at the beginning.

Some quotes I enjoyed:

"Andrew Carnegie said that if you die rich, you die disgraced. Well, Mother will be safe with Andrew, if they meet in heaven. She'd been living beyond her means for years. Way beyond." (Page 4).

"Apparently once Rachel threw his suits into the bathtub and set them on fire so he wouldn't have anything to wear to work. That's not normal. But I begin to think there may well have been two sides to that story." (Page 28). You don't say...

"There are always two sides in a marriage. Always. At least two." (Page 28).

"Once I understood where the ring came from, I wanted it. It's hard, dividing this stuff. It isn't really bits of stone and metal and wood. It's the history of our family. Who loved who, who was cruel, who was kind." (Page 52). On a larger scale, this is why we need archeologists and indeed the entire field of archeology.

"I once worked in a school where they'd had a really pugnacious head. He couldn't get along with anyone, although he'd come with great recommendations. Turns out the last school gave him glowing recs because they wanted to get rid of him." (Page 62). I laughed so hard. ( )
  Jennifer708 | Mar 21, 2020 |
Well written family story but I was a bit bored by it. ( )
  Smits | Sep 28, 2018 |
3.5 STARS.....i enjoyed but i would not suggest anyone rush out to buy it sad to say. I read Leeway Cottage awhile back and am glad i did, it's almost a necessity.
Fiction based on fact including pictures, this is a generational story about a family and a summer home in Maine. Good story! But there were so many references to people from the other book, the past, that it made the reading a wee bit confusing.
THAT SAID: I WOULD read another by this author. ( )
  lineells | Oct 19, 2017 |
Had to give this one up too. It was written like a play. Too many characters all fighting over their dead parents stuff. Ugg. Why can't I pick up a good book! ( )
  amusedbybooks | Dec 9, 2010 |
If you have not read Ms. Gutcheon's novel, Leeway Cottage I fear you will be hard-pressed to make a lot of sense out of this book. However, if you were a fan of that earlier novel, you'll enjoy catching up with Sydney & Laurus' children as they try to divide their inheritance in Dundee, Maine after the death of their parents.

Told through the voices of the many participants in their lives, and a little bit like reading random Facebook postings, the novel is a bit like fitting a jig-saw puzzle together & I ended up being grateful for the glossary of characters that the author supplied at the end of the book.

I don't think this novel really worked stylistically, but I so enjoyed the book that it's a sequel to, that I kept reading all the way to the end. ( )
  etxgardener | May 23, 2010 |
Goodbye and Amen is a contemporary family drama with a large cast of characters. It begins as three adult children are dividing up the family heirlooms following their parents’ deaths. The story follows all three families, including the spouses and children, and pulls in assorted neighbors, friends, coworkers, and assorted bystanders along the way.

The format is unusual. The story is told in little “bursts” of one or a few paragraphs from a particular character, and then switches to another character. It took me a few pages to get used to it, but I found it quite enjoyable. The phrasing of each “burst” is very conversational – I could almost “hear” each character talking to me. I got the sense of being at a party, milling around collecting the gossip from various people. Or of watching a montage of television interviews, getting just the sound bites without the interviewer’s questions. Each character’s personality really comes through just in their perspective of events and the wording they choose.

There is one character who has passed on, and is sharing his lofty wisdom from the great beyond. I didn’t enjoy this perspective as much as the other characters, as it didn’t seem to fit with the daily concerns and everyday personalities of the rest of the ensemble. Perhaps that was the point, and it was just lost on me. I may have appreciated this voice more had I already read Leeway Cottage (the prequel). ( )
1 vote SugarCreekRanch | Sep 4, 2009 |
This was a disappointing follow up to Leeway Cottage. The format is ambitious and interesting, with the characters taking turns in telling the story. The format wasn't the problem with this novel, it was the fact that the characters were pretty uniformly uninteresting and shallow. The dismantling of an estate, with the siblings vying for favorite belongings and keepsakes, isn't necessarily the most sympathetic way to portray characters. The members of the Moss family essentially come across as self-satisfied and privileged. The most interesting sections of the book, and the shortest, were the observations and comments from the people who were not family members but who had to deal with the self-absorbed and selfish Mosses. Somehow, in Leeway Cottage, Gutcheon managed to make this group appealing while still showing their many shortcomings. This time around, not so much. This was disappointing to me since Gutcheon's past efforts have always struck me as readable and entertaining. ( )
  lmikkel | Jul 5, 2009 |
A disappointing follow-up to the very enjoyable Leeway Cottage. The last third of the book was interesting but this book is definitely not for anyone who hasn't read and enjoyed Leeway. ( )
  Copperskye | Sep 26, 2008 |
hard to read with all the different people representing themselves and talking. Monica faithful and her husband the preacher Norman and a silly family. I really didn't like it ( )
  hammockqueen | Sep 1, 2008 |
Showing 11 of 11

Current Discussions

None

Popular covers

Quick Links

Rating

Average: (3)
0.5 1
1 2
1.5
2 3
2.5 1
3 13
3.5 2
4 9
4.5
5

Is this you?

Become a LibraryThing Author.

 

About | Contact | Privacy/Terms | Help/FAQs | Blog | Store | APIs | TinyCat | Legacy Libraries | Early Reviewers | Common Knowledge | 216,749,662 books! | Top bar: Always visible
  NODES
Project 1