Click on a thumbnail to go to Google Books.
Loading... On Saudi Arabia: Its People, Past, Religion, Fault Lines - and Futureby Karen Elliott House
None Loading...
Sign up for LibraryThing to find out whether you'll like this book. No current Talk conversations about this book. There are several messages in this book all pointing to problems. None of them are at the boiling point, but the combination is in danger of coalescing to a crisis. - The royal line is old, numerous, and almost powerless in effecting change. - Royal succession has been contentious and will continue to be a problem. - There are a ton of princes. - Some of the people live in extreme poverty. - The young men don't want to work except at cushy government jobs. - The people have a sense of entitlement. - Large handouts don't improve the prospects for country stability, they only reinforce the entitlement mentality. - Since working is beneath the Saudi, most of the non-government jobs are filled by foreigners. - The unemployment rate is sky high; for 20-24 year olds 39% (45.5% for women and 30.3% for men). - Women aren't allowed in most jobs because they might come in contact with men. - The educational system is really bad (teaching is unacceptable to the Saudi young men, and the women aren't allowed to teach classes with male students). - Religion dominates their lives. - The religious system is oppressive. - Religion was used by the government to control the people. - Religion hampers the government's ability to improve the country. - Religious study squeezes out secular study & is largely memorization. - Religious police are viewed by the author as a massive damper on improving the lot of the people. - Religious leaders are divided along the radical - conservative spectrum. - The Internet makes it easy for the young to see the conflicts, inequity, and ineffectiveness of their government... - An exception (in many ways) is Saudi ARAMCO. Many of these points were reiterated throughout the book perhaps to make sure that the reader didn't miss them. The reiteration was not annoying, but came across more as elaboration on a theme or as weaving themes together. A few interesting statements. "This resignation to living under corrupt temporal leaders and focusing not on improving life on earth but rather on securing a better life in the hereafter helps explain why oppressive and greedy rulers reign for so long in so many Arab countries." (Page 29) "If Westerners love individualism, most Saudis are literally frightened at the mere thought of being different. To be different is to attract attention. To attract attention is to invite envy from peers and anger from family." (Page 31) "The average age of the king and crown prince is 83, yet, as already noted, 60 percent of Saudis are under twenty. "(Page 221) Thus, they have very different value. How can those leaders satisfy the desires of the youthful population? "Saudi Arabia is like a rich schoolboy and teacher's pet that seeks to mask his dependence on the teacher's protection by currying favor with the schoolyard bullies. While he goes to great lengths to avoid being seen as the teacher's pet, he also frets that the teacher will be upset at the bad company he is keeping. As a result, he is not respected or trusted by anyone." (Page 230) The last few chapters sum it all up, so if you are not up to reading the whole thing, just read the end. However, the whole book is written in an interesting style. I have read a few books on the middle east and studied middle eastern history in college 30 years ago. So, not much of an expert. With that caveat I found the book to be highly enlightening. Especially found the chapters discussing the current and future prognoses for a shift in the role of the monarchy cause for concern. Although long a stable ally to the US the book highlighted the true precariousness of that view. I very much liked the chapter on the attempts of the Saud to rehabilitate the young jihadi. A well written book the doesn't seem to varnish or pull punches. A solid overview of the Kingdom of the House of Saud, covering topics such as the role of religion, the Wahhabi sect, the role of women, economic inequality, foreign labor importation, and of course, oil. Saudi Arabia as a US-backed absolute monarchic counterweight to Iran, although relations have been more than a bit strained over the past few years. Her characterization of Saudi Arabia as a gerontocracy, similar to that of the stagnant Soviet Union in the 1980s, is particularly apt - the reining monarch and some of his immediate successors are 60 years of age - and half the population is 20 or younger. The only (very minor) flaw I have is that the author has a tendency to use mixed metaphor - Saudi Arabia is a shadow, a labyrinth, a wall, etc. This is only a matter of personal preference, however, and I found this to be a very solid introduction to a complex place. no reviews | add a review
History.
Politics.
Sociology.
Nonfiction.
HTML: From the Pulitzer Prize–winning reporter who has spent the last thirty years writing about Saudi Arabia—as diplomatic correspondent, foreign editor, and then publisher of The Wall Street Journal—an important and timely book that explores all facets of life in this shrouded Kingdom: its tribal past, its complicated present, its precarious future. No library descriptions found. |
Current DiscussionsNonePopular covers
Google Books — Loading... GenresMelvil Decimal System (DDC)953.8History & geography History of Asia Arabian Peninsula and adjacent areas Saudi ArabiaLC ClassificationRatingAverage:
Is this you?Become a LibraryThing Author. |
In her preface, she claimed to be in touch with this country for over 30 years. Unfortunately, she delivers a mix of Wikipedia injected with American media narrative with steroids.
If you’ve watched power puff girls, the cartoon starts with Professor Utonium mixing sugar, spice and everything nice. He stirs all the ingredients and poof, Power Puff Girls appear (drum rolls). In a similar fashion, Wikipedia, Fox News CNBC and inject a bad narrative — poof this book appears.
The more I read, I became disappointed. If you walk over to an Average Joe in the West, he would regurgitate the same info and narrative of this book. Unfortunately, if this is where people in the West learn about a society which is non-Western, I say it’s bad scholarship.
I do not practice Islam. However, I want to take an effort in understanding a culture which I am not familiar. I'd rather not paint a narrative. Eg: "Wahhab preached a pure version of his Islam" Well, I am ignorant on various theological factions of Islam.
I am a non-Westerner reading this book. I am also a non-Saudi. I am a casual yet extremely curious observer of other-cultures. I wish, I could hear what a scholar who grew up in the Middle East comment on this society. A Scholar who has lived in both worlds.
Oh, I can think of Patrick Smith who wrote a book on, "Somebody Else's Century." He's a Westerner living in Asia (China, Japan, India). He was able to understand Asia (China, Japan, India) far more than any Westerner that I have encountered.
Patrick was more aware of intricate social concepts which are absent in the West.
I would not recommend this book to learn about Saudi Arabia. I am not sure what to recommend.
Deus Vult,
Gottfried ( )