I felt about this one like I did about the first in the series: I wish Hornby had been given more freedom to review as he saw fit, but these short pieces are still generally amusing. ( )

These collections are just the thing for book nuts. And Hornby fans. And anyone stuck on what to read next. If you ever find yourself in one of those slumps, pick up one of these little volumes. They're effortless and charming and fun, and they make you want to read. ( )

collection of columns on books read, orig printed in Believer

“Housekeeping vs. the Dirt,” published in 2006, is another in a series of collections of Nick Hornby's delightful columns printed monthly, or almost monthly, in Believer. That his column does not appear every month is something of a running joke in these columns, which ran from February 2005 to June/July 2006. From time to time Hornby comments about being suspended by the magazine's editors for making negative comments about the books he reviews. They supposedly tolerate only positive reviews. Yet Hornby's comments about the magazine, his editors and himself are often so fanciful that one doesn't always know what should be believed. Only when writing about books and literature in general does his commentary seem sincere and trustworthy.

At the top of each column Hornby lists both the books bought that month (although he also includes books given to him) and the books read that month. Then he writes about the books he read in a stew of an essay that mixes in other commentary, as well.

He reads quite a variety of books, mostly in the middle range between the high-brow and low-brow extremes and mostly contemporary books. Yet he does comment on Voltaire's “Candide,” G.K. Chesterton's “The Man Who Was Thursday” and Robert Warren's “All the King's Men,” each a classic from years gone by. Naturally the commentary that most interests me is that about books I've read and appreciated, such as Jess Walter's “Citizen Vince,” Marilynne Robinson's “Gilead,” Michael Frayn's “”Spies” and “The Trick of It” and Tom Perrotta's “Little Children.” He likes them, too, and one believes that his positive reviews are not just the result of some edict from Believer editors.

Hornby's book also includes a few brief excerpts from books he reviews that may entice readers to try them even if his reviews do not.

Hornby is himself a novelist, the author of such books as “About a Boy” and “A Long Way Down.”

If you think books reviews have to be stuffy, read Hornby's columns and think again. ( )

Housekeeping vs. the Dirt was one of the first books I ever added to my Amazon wish list oh so many years ago. Now I've finally read it!

Essentially a list of all the books he bought and read over a 17 month period, it's almost shocking to me that I have only read one of them (Into the Wild). Despite my unfamiliarity with the material, I really enjoyed reading Hornby's take on all of these works.

Although Hornby isn't my favorite all-time author, he is the author who's writing I most enjoy to read. (I feel like he'd like to twist that sentiment right around at me.)

Not the kind of collection I'd ever revisit, but I chuckled out loud (COL) a few times and now I have a few more books to add the the old TBR. ( )