Sorry to be a party pooper, but this seems pointless to me, with no successful humor or heart. It sort of reminded me of my minor itchiness, but that's not funny imo, rather, it's annoying. ( )

A bunch of dinosaurs see a sign that says "Dinosaurs Do Not Scratch" so they decide to be tough dinosaurs who refuse the urge to scratch -- but they are all so itchy!

This was a humorous book, especially with the reveal at the end. There isn't really a message or anything like that, but kids will enjoy getting a laugh out of the characters' antics. Of course, being book-ended by Gerald and Piggie doesn't hurt either!

The illustrations are unlike Pham's typical more realistic style, but they work for this silly story. My only quibble is that the "Dinosaurs Do Not Scratch" sign looks a little bit like a tombstone. ( )

So popular with my students. ( )

This is part of the Elephant and Piggie Like Reading series; each title is introduced with popular characters Elephant and Piggie in a brief exchange and finishes with another comic interlude with the pair. I was surprised to realize I hadn't reviewed this one, since I must have read it 20 times last spring with class visits!

Piggie introduces the story by asking Gerald if he likes books that make you "feel things" and when Gerald confirms that yes, he does, the story begins! We first see a black and grey stone with "dinosaurs do not scratch" carved into it and a turtle sleeping below the words. A bespectacled orange-brown dinosaur, dressed in blue t-shirt and white shorts, reads the stone and is surprised to learn something new... when a triceratops happens along. When they start to scratch, the first dinosaur points out the stone and the fun begins... naturally, once they've been forbidden to do so, more and more dinosaurs show up with a desperate need to scratch! The first dinosaur is strong though - nothing will make them scratch! Not grass clippings, ants, itchy sweaters, nothing! Only one thing can make them scratch... when the turtle finally moves and the rest of the carved words appear!

Elephant and Piggie finish the story with some funny words about scratching - and friends. Pham's colorful art is sprinkled with speech balloons in different colors, including some comic panels. This title fits well into the Elephant and Piggie series, even though it's much more colorful, including backgrounds and lots of details. Emerging readers may find it difficult to follow, with the many different colors and some variety in fonts, but readers at approximately a first grade, beginning level will have no problem. It also makes a great read-aloud!

Verdict: While not a top pick for actual reading mechanics, this is certainly a top pick for fun! Beginning readers are sure to enjoy the continuation of Elephant and Piggie's adventures as well as Pham's artwork and silly story for their own merits.

ISBN: 9781368005647; Published May 2018 by Hyperion; Purchased 2 copies for the library

This is cute, but I’m not sure I “get” it. I love the E and P series and Mo Willems, and I get what their *trying* to do, but I think this misses the mark. Maybe when I read it to a group of students it’ll make more sense? This is a story of dinosaurs, a turtle, and a rock with a sign: “Dinosaurs don’t scratch”. As different itchy dinosaurs come by, they are reminded that dinosaurs don’t scratch. What will happen with all these itchy dinosaurs? The dinosaurs try to prove how tough they are and how they don’t need to scratch, until the turtle moves and reveals the whole sign: “Dinosaurs don’t scratch ... alone!” ( )